A Case Study in the Limits of the TWM Safeguard
The power of the courts to certify an application as "Totally Without Merit" (TWM) is one of the more consequential tools in civil procedure. A TWM certification under CPR 23.12 does not merely dispose of an application; it can trigger an extended civil restraint order, strip a litigant of the right to apply for permission to appeal, and, in practice, close off a case from further judicial consideration altogether.
Because the consequences are so severe, the Court of Appeal has repeatedly emphasised that TWM certification should not be made lightly. Judges are expected to take what has been described as "peculiar care" to ensure that the substance of an argument or ground has been properly engaged with before a case is dismissed as hopeless, precisely because the certification forecloses the ordinary right of appeal that would otherwise correct an error.
That safeguard only functions, however, if the underlying evidence said to found the application is actually considered. A TWM certification made without engagement with the central documentary evidence is not a safeguard operating as intended, it is a procedural shortcut operating in its place.
The Perseus Ventures case
Our investigation examined the litigation history of Perseus Ventures Limited v Foskett and others (KB-2024-001774), a High Court dispute concerning the sale of a residential property in Rotherhithe, London, and the handling of the net proceeds of that sale by receivers appointed over the property.
The property was sold on 5 September 2024. HM Land Registry's title register records the consideration for that sale as £841,000. That figure is not, on the material we have reviewed, disputed by any party. What our investigation found striking is that this figure, the actual gross sum received by the receivers on completion, does not appear to feature in any of the substantive judgments or orders made in the proceedings that followed, including a judgment delivered in mid-2026 and a subsequent order refusing permission to bring further proceedings. Instead, the sum treated throughout as representing "the proceeds of sale" was a considerably smaller figure, said to be a residual balance after deduction of loan redemption and receivership costs.
A reconciliation exercise, redemption figure subtracted from completion price, is arithmetic, not adjudication. Whether or not the deductions claimed by the receivers were proper is a matter for evidence and findings of fact. But a reconciliation cannot be tested, challenged, or ruled upon if the starting figure from which it must proceed is never identified in the judgment at all. On the material we reviewed, one order in the case itself acknowledged that "the precise sum that the Claimant was, or should have been, entitled to as the net proceeds of sale... has not previously been determined by the Courts" — a finding that sits uneasily with a subsequent certification that the claim seeking to establish that very sum was totally without merit.
Why this matters beyond one case
The concern this case raises is not that a particular outcome was wrong, appellate courts exist to correct wrong outcomes, and this article takes no position on how the underlying financial dispute should ultimately be resolved.
The concern is structural: a TWM certification removes the very mechanism, appeal, through which an error of this kind would normally be identified and corrected.
If a central, undisputed figure can go unaddressed in a judgment that nonetheless certifies an application as hopeless, the "peculiar care" standard that the Court of Appeal has prescribed as the safeguard against exactly this risk has not, on the facts of this case, visibly been demonstrated in the written outcome.That is a fair trial issue, not merely a procedural one.
Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights guarantees a right to a fair and public hearing in the determination of civil rights and obligations.
A certification process that can end litigation without the central disputed sum being engaged with on the face of the judgment raises a legitimate question as to whether that engagement in fact took place, a question appellate courts and, where appropriate, judicial conduct mechanisms are better placed to answer than a journalistic investigation.
Perseus Ventures Limited has taken its case to the Court of Appeal, on appeal of the 31 July 2026 judgment by Dias J.
We will publish the next report following hand down of the permission to appeal decision.



